Horayot 8
Share this shiur:
This week’s learning is sponsored by Hadran zoom for the celebration of the many smachot that Hashem has blessed our community. “From aliya to children’s engagements, from grandchildren’s health to the many many new children and grandchildren and great grandchildren, from grandchildren’s weddings and engagements to the daf yomi-relevant pidyon haben of sons and grandsons. Mazal tov to all who celebrated personally and to all of us.”
This week’s learning is sponsored by Audrey Mondrow in loving memory of her father, Irving “Poppy” Mauskopf, Yechezkel ben Rachel v’Avraham, and in honor of the bar mitzvah of her grandson, Yechezkel ben Rachel. “My father was a man who greeted everyone with a smile and had complete emuna. May his neshama have an aliya. My grandson was born as my father was being buried, and he carries his name.”
This week’s learning is sponsored by Ruth Rotenberg in loving memory of Naftali Hertz haKohen, Hart Rotenberg, whose 1st yahrzeit just passed. “At 99 years, you left a legacy of love for family, Torah and Israel.”
Want to dedicate learning? Get started here:

Summary
Rebbi and the rabbis disagree about the case in which a kohen gadol becomes obligated to bring a sacrifice for idol worship. According to one view, it involves a situation where he unknowingly worshipped idols. According to the other, it refers to a case where he unknowingly issued an erroneous halakhic ruling and then acted upon it. Despite this disagreement, both Rebbi and the rabbis agree that the sacrifice he brings is the same as that brought by an individual—a female goat. They also concur that the kohen gadol does not bring a provisional guilt offering (asham talui), though each derives this conclusion through a different method.
The communal sin offering—whether for general commandments or for idol worship—is only brought for transgressions where intentional violation incurs karet, and unintentional violation requires a sin offering. This same criterion applies to the unique sin offering of the kohen gadol, the king and the individual. Rebbi derives this from a gezera shava based on the word עליה (“upon her”), which appears both in the verse about the communal offering and in the verse prohibiting a man from sleeping with his wife’s sister. The rabbis, however, interpret the verse about the sister differently for another law, and instead derive the principle from Bamidbar (Numbers) 15:29–30. What does Rebbi derive from that verse?
How do we know that the section in Bamidbar 15 refers specifically to the sin of idol worship? Three suggestions are offered, though the third is ultimately rejected.
The communal sin offering is not brought for transgressions that are punishable by a sliding scale offering (korban oleh ve’yored). The source for this exclusion is also examined.
Does the king bring his unique sin offering for a transgression that is punishable by a sliding scale offering? The Mishna presents two differing opinions on this matter.
Today’s daily daf tools:
This week’s learning is sponsored by Hadran zoom for the celebration of the many smachot that Hashem has blessed our community. “From aliya to children’s engagements, from grandchildren’s health to the many many new children and grandchildren and great grandchildren, from grandchildren’s weddings and engagements to the daf yomi-relevant pidyon haben of sons and grandsons. Mazal tov to all who celebrated personally and to all of us.”
This week’s learning is sponsored by Audrey Mondrow in loving memory of her father, Irving “Poppy” Mauskopf, Yechezkel ben Rachel v’Avraham, and in honor of the bar mitzvah of her grandson, Yechezkel ben Rachel. “My father was a man who greeted everyone with a smile and had complete emuna. May his neshama have an aliya. My grandson was born as my father was being buried, and he carries his name.”
This week’s learning is sponsored by Ruth Rotenberg in loving memory of Naftali Hertz haKohen, Hart Rotenberg, whose 1st yahrzeit just passed. “At 99 years, you left a legacy of love for family, Torah and Israel.”
Today’s daf is dedicated in memory of the six civilians killed in yesterday’s terrorist incident and the four tank soldiers killed in action in Gaza. Yehi zichram baruch.
Today’s daily daf tools:
Delve Deeper
Broaden your understanding of the topics on this daf with classes and podcasts from top women Talmud scholars.
New to Talmud?
Check out our resources designed to help you navigate a page of Talmud – and study at the pace, level and style that fits you.
The Hadran Women’s Tapestry
Meet the diverse women learning Gemara at Hadran and hear their stories.






















