Search

Avodah Zarah 72

Want to dedicate learning? Get started here:

podcast placeholder

0:00
0:00




Summary

The resolution to the second difficulty against Rav Ashi’s position is rejected, and the Gemara concludes that pulling does affect acquisition for a non-Jew.

The Mishna on Avodah Zarah 71 stresses the issue of agreement on price as a precondition for acquisition. Some situations arose regarding this issue in selling property. At first, Rav Yosef and Abaye disagree about whether or not the same principle applies in a sale, as the Mishna only discussed it about yayin nesech. However, the Gemara concludes that Abaye is correct, that the same logic applies for both, based on a ruling of Rav Huna, which was based on a Mishna in Bava Batra 85b. However, in a different case, there is a further debate about whether this holds, albeit under more unique circumstances.

The Mishna discusses two cases. In the first case, a Jew pours wine through a funnel into the non-Jew’s jug. If there are some droplets of wine in the funnel, they are prohibited. If the Jew pours wine from a vessel into another vessel, the wine in the first vessel is permitted, while the wine in the second vessel is prohibited.

The Gemara first quotes a Mishna in Taharot 8:9 relating to the issue of nitzok, a stream of water, as regards impurity. If water that streams down becomes impure, i.e., is poured into an impure vessel, it does not affect the water at the top that has not entered the vessel. Rav Huna, however, ruled that the upper liquid would be forbidden in a parallel case of yayin nesech.

Today’s daily daf tools:

Avodah Zarah 72

וּמַאי ״לֹא נִיתַּן לְהִישָּׁבוֹן״? דְּאֵינוֹ בְּתוֹרַת הִישָּׁבוֹן.

And what does it mean that the stolen object is not subject to restitution? It means that it is not subject to the halakhot of restitution, because it is not technically a theft.

אִי הָכִי, אֵימָא סֵיפָא: בָּא חֲבֵירוֹ וּנְטָלָהּ מִמֶּנּוּ — נֶהֱרָג עָלֶיהָ. בִּשְׁלָמָא רֵישָׁא, מִשּׁוּם דְּצַעֲרֵיהּ לְיִשְׂרָאֵל, אֶלָּא סֵיפָא, מַאי עָבֵיד?

The Gemara asks: If that is so, say the latter clause of that halakhic statement: If another descendant of Noah came and took the stolen item from him, he is also executed for it. Granted, with regard to the first clause it can be explained that although there is no obligation to return the item, the gentile is executed because he caused the Jew distress; but with regard to the latter clause, what did he do? He did not cause the Jew distress, and since the item is worth less than one peruta, one is not obligated to return it unless he stole it from a gentile. Consequently, the second theft should not be considered a legally significant act.

אֶלָּא שְׁמַע מִינַּהּ, מְשִׁיכָה בְּגוֹי קוֹנָה, שְׁמַע מִינַּהּ.

Rather, should one not conclude from it that one pulling an item acquires it in a transaction performed by a gentile? Accordingly, the actions of both the first and second gentiles are legally significant acts of theft, for which they are liable to be executed. The Gemara affirms: Conclude from it that this is so.

הָהוּא גַּבְרָא דַּאֲמַר לֵיהּ לְחַבְרֵיהּ: ״אִי מְזַבֵּינְנָא לַהּ לְהָא אַרְעָא — לָךְ מְזַבֵּינְנָא לַהּ״, אֲזַל זַבְּנַהּ לְאִינִישׁ אַחֲרִינָא, אֲמַר רַב יוֹסֵף: קְנָה קַמָּא.

§ The Gemara relates: There was an incident involving a certain man who said to another: If I sell this land, I will sell it to you, and they performed a formal act of acquisition to ratify the agreement. He went and sold it to another person. Rav Yosef said: The first one has acquired it.

אֲמַר לֵיהּ אַבָּיֵי: וְהָא לָא פְּסַק! וּמְנָא תֵּימְרָא דְּכֹל הֵיכָא דְּלָא פְּסַק לָא קְנָה? דִּתְנַן: הַמּוֹכֵר יֵינוֹ לְנׇכְרִי, פָּסַק עַד שֶׁלֹּא מָדַד — דָּמָיו מוּתָּרִין, מָדַד עַד שֶׁלֹּא פָּסַק — דָּמָיו אֲסוּרִין.

Abaye said to him: But he did not fix a price with him for it. And from where do you say that wherever the people involved in the transaction did not fix a price, the buyer has not acquired the item, even if they performed a formal act of acquisition? It is from that which we learned in the mishna: In the case of a Jew who sells his wine to a gentile, if he fixed a price before he measured the wine into the gentile’s vessel, deriving benefit from the money paid for the wine is permitted. But if the Jew measured the wine into the gentile’s vessel, thereby rendering it forbidden, before he fixed a price, the money paid for the wine is forbidden.

מַאי הָוֵי עֲלַהּ? מַאי הָוֵי עֲלַהּ?! כִּדְקָאָמְרִינַן! דִּלְמָא חוּמְרָא דְּיֵין נֶסֶךְ שָׁאנֵי.

The Gemara asks: What halakhic conclusion was reached about this matter? The Gemara interjects: What is meant by the question: What halakhic conclusion was reached about this matter? The conclusion is as we have stated, that it is evident from the mishna that the acquisition goes into effect only after the price is fixed. The Gemara explains its question: Perhaps due to the stringency of the prohibition of wine used for a libation, the case of the mishna is different and is not characteristic of the halakha in monetary matters.

תָּא שְׁמַע, דְּאָמַר רַב אִידִי בַּר אָבִין: עוֹבָדָא הֲוָה בֵּי רַב חִסְדָּא, וְרַב חִסְדָּא בֵּי רַב הוּנָא, וּפַשְׁטֻיהָ מֵהָא דִּתְנַן: מָשַׁךְ חֲמָרָיו וּפוֹעֲלָיו וְהִכְנִיסָן לְתוֹךְ בֵּיתוֹ, בֵּין פָּסַק עַד שֶׁלֹּא מָדַד וּבֵין מָדַד עַד שֶׁלֹּא פָּסַק — לֹא קָנָה, וּשְׁנֵיהֶן יְכוֹלִין לַחֲזוֹר בָּהֶן.

The Gemara suggests: Come and hear a proof that an acquisition goes into effect only after the price is fixed, as Rav Idi bar Avin said: There was an incident that came before the school of Rav Ḥisda, and Rav Ḥisda brought it before the school of Rav Huna, and Rav Huna resolved it from that which we learned in a baraita: If one bought from another produce that was loaded on the seller’s donkeys or carried by his laborers, and the purchaser drew the seller’s donkey drivers or laborers laden with produce and brought them into his house, in this case, whether the seller fixed a price before he measured the produce or whether he measured the produce before he fixed a price, the purchaser has not acquired the produce, and both of them, the purchaser or the seller, can retract the transaction, as no act of acquisition took place.

פֵּרְקָן וְהִכְנִיסָן לְתוֹךְ בֵּיתוֹ, פָּסַק עַד שֶׁלֹּא מָדַד — אֵין שְׁנֵיהֶן יְכוֹלִין לַחֲזוֹר בָּהֶן, מָדַד עַד שֶׁלֹּא פָּסַק — שְׁנֵיהֶן יְכוֹלִין לַחֲזוֹר בָּהֶן.

The baraita continues: But if the purchaser unloaded the produce and brought it into his house, this constitutes an act of acquisition, and therefore if he fixed a price before he measured the produce, neither of them can retract, but if he measured the produce before he fixed a price, both of them can retract. This illustrates that even if there was an act of acquisition, they can retract the transaction until the price has been fixed, in accordance with the statement of Abaye.

הָהוּא גַּבְרָא דַּאֲמַר לֵיהּ לְחַבְרֵיהּ: ״אִי מְזַבֵּינְנָא לַהּ לְהָא אַרְעָא — מְזַבֵּינְנָא לָךְ בִּמְאָה זוּזֵי״, אֲזַל זַבְּנַהּ לְאִינִישׁ אַחֲרִינָא בִּמְאָה וְעֶשְׂרִין. אָמַר רַב כָּהֲנָא: קְנָה קַמָּא. מַתְקֵיף לַהּ רַב יַעֲקֹב מִנְּהַר פְּקוֹד: הַאי זוּזֵי אַנְסוּהּ! וְהִלְכְתָא כְּרַב יַעֲקֹב מִנְּהַר פְּקוֹד.

§ There was a related incident involving a certain man who said to another: If I will desire to sell this land, I will sell it to you for one hundred dinars, and they performed an act of acquisition to ratify the agreement. He went and sold it to another person for one hundred and twenty dinars. Rav Kahana said: The first one has acquired it. Rav Ya’akov of Nehar Pekod objects to this: Those twenty additional dinars compelled him to sell it to the second purchaser. The Gemara concludes: And the halakha is in accordance with the opinion of Rav Ya’akov of Nehar Pekod.

אֲמַר לֵיהּ ״כִּדְשָׁיְימִי בִּתְלָתָא״ — אֲפִילּוּ תְּרֵי מִגּוֹ תְּלָתָא. ״כִּדְאָמְרִי בִּתְלָתָא״ — עַד דְּאָמְרִי בִּתְלָתָא. ״כִּדְשָׁיְימִי בְּאַרְבְּעָה״ — עַד דְּאָמְרִי בְּאַרְבָּעָה, וְכׇל שֶׁכֵּן הֵיכָא דַּאֲמַר לֵיהּ ״כִּדְאָמְרִי בְּאַרְבָּעָה״.

§ If the seller said to the purchaser: I will sell you this merchandise as it is assessed by three people, even if two out of the three agreed to a certain assessment, the seller must accept this price. If he said: I will sell you this merchandise in accordance with the price that is stated by three people, he is not held to their assessment unless it is stated by all three. If he said: As it is assessed by four people, he is not held to their assessment unless it is stated by all four; and all the more so in a case where he said to him: In accordance with the price that is stated by four people.

אֲמַר לֵיהּ: ״כִּדְשָׁיְימִי בִּתְלָתָא״, וַאֲתוֹ תְּלָתָא וְשָׁמוּהָ, וַאֲמַר לֵיהּ אִידַּךְ: לֵיתוֹ תְּלָתָא אַחֲרִינֵי דְּקִים לְהוּ טְפֵי! אָמַר רַב פָּפָּא: דִּינָא הוּא דִּמְעַכֵּב. מַתְקֵיף לַהּ רַב הוּנָא בְּרֵיהּ דְּרַב יְהוֹשֻׁעַ: מִמַּאי דְּהָנֵי קִים לְהוּ טְפֵי? דִּלְמָא הָנֵי קִים לְהוּ טְפֵי! וְהִלְכְתָא כְּרַב הוּנָא בְּרֵיהּ דְּרַב יְהוֹשֻׁעַ.

If the seller said to the buyer: I will sell you this merchandise as it is assessed by three people, and three people came and assessed it, and the other one, the purchaser, said: Let three other people, who are more proficient in their assessment, come and assess the merchandise, Rav Pappa said: The halakha is that he can prevent the price from being set until more proficient people assess the merchandise. Rav Huna, son of Rav Yehoshua, objects to this: From where can he know that those other three are more proficient in their assessment? Perhaps these, the first three, are more proficient. The Gemara concludes: And the halakha is in accordance with the opinion of Rav Huna, son of Rav Yehoshua.

מַתְנִי׳ נָטַל אֶת הַמַּשְׁפֵּךְ וּמָדַד לְתוֹךְ צְלוֹחִיתוֹ שֶׁל נׇכְרִי, וְחָזַר וּמָדַד לְתוֹךְ צְלוֹחִיתוֹ שֶׁל יִשְׂרָאֵל, אִם יֵשׁ בּוֹ עַכֶּבֶת יַיִן — אָסוּר. הַמְעָרֶה מִכְּלִי אֶל כְּלִי, אֶת שֶׁעֵירָה מִמֶּנּוּ — מוּתָּר, וְאֶת שֶׁעֵירָה לְתוֹכוֹ — אָסוּר.

MISHNA: In a case where a Jew took a funnel and measured wine into a gentile’s jug, and then measured wine with the same funnel into a Jew’s jug, if there is a remnant of wine left in the funnel, the wine measured into the Jew’s jug is forbidden, as some of the wine that was measured into the gentile’s jug is mixed in it. In the case of one who pours wine from one vessel into another vessel, the wine left in the vessel from which he poured is permitted, but the wine in the vessel into which he poured is forbidden.

גְּמָ׳ תְּנַן הָתָם: הַנִּצּוֹק, וְהַקָּטַפְרֵס, וּמַשְׁקֶה טוֹפֵחַ — אֵינוֹ חִיבּוּר, לֹא לְטוּמְאָה וְלֹא לְטׇהֳרָה. הָאַשְׁבּוֹרֶן — חִיבּוּר לְטוּמְאָה וּלְטׇהֳרָה.

GEMARA: We learned in a mishna elsewhere (Teharot 8:9): A stream of water, and water descending an incline [vehakatafres], and liquid that rendered an item moist do not constitute a connection between liquids, neither with regard to ritual impurity nor with regard to purity. These liquids do not constitute a connection that transmits impurity, e.g., if impure water is in one place and becomes attached to water above it, the water above is not considered attached to the impure water and is not rendered impure. They also do not constitute a connection for purification, e.g., if two collections of water are attached via the pouring of a stream, they do not join together to form the amount of water necessary to form a valid ritual bath, through which people and items can become ritually pure. A pond constitutes a connection between liquids with regard to impurity and with regard to purity.

אָמַר רַב הוּנָא: נִצּוֹק וְקָטַפְרֵס וּמַשְׁקֶה טוֹפֵחַ חִיבּוּר לְעִנְיַן יֵין נֶסֶךְ.

Rav Huna says: A stream of water, and water descending an incline, and liquid that rendered an item moist constitute a connection with regard to the matter of wine used for a libation.

אֲמַר לֵיהּ רַב נַחְמָן לְרַב הוּנָא: מְנָא לָךְ הָא? אִילֵּימָא מִדִּתְנַן: הַנִּצּוֹק וְהַקָּטַפְרֵס וּמַשְׁקֶה טוֹפֵחַ אֵינוֹ חִיבּוּר לֹא לְטוּמְאָה וְלֹא לְטׇהֳרָה, לְטוּמְאָה וּלְטׇהֳרָה הוּא דְּלָא הָוֵי חִיבּוּר, הָא לְעִנְיַן יֵין נֶסֶךְ הָוֵי חִיבּוּר — אֵימָא סֵיפָא: הָאַשְׁבּוֹרֶן חִיבּוּר לְטוּמְאָה וּלְטׇהֳרָה, לְטוּמְאָה וּלְטׇהֳרָה הוּא דְּהָוֵי חִיבּוּר, הָא לְעִנְיַן יֵין נֶסֶךְ לָא הָוֵי חִיבּוּר. אֶלָּא מֵהָא לֵיכָּא לְמִשְׁמַע מִינַּהּ.

Rav Naḥman said to Rav Huna: From where do you derive this? If we say it is derived from that which we learned in the mishna: A stream, and water descending an incline, and liquid that rendered an item moist do not constitute a connection between liquids, neither with regard to ritual impurity nor with regard to purity, and it is inferred that it is with regard to impurity and with regard to purity that it does not constitute a connection, but with regard to wine used for a libation it does constitute a connection, then say the latter clause: A pond constitutes a connection between liquids with regard to impurity and with regard to purity. It can be inferred from here that with regard to impurity and with regard to purity it is a connection, but with regard to wine used for a libation it is not a connection, contrary to the halakha inferred from the former clause. Rather, clearly no inference is to be learned from this mishna.

תְּנַן: נָטַל אֶת הַמַּשְׁפֵּךְ וּמָדַד לְתוֹךְ צְלוֹחִיתוֹ שֶׁל נׇכְרִי, וְחָזַר וּמָדַד לְתוֹךְ צְלוֹחִיתוֹ שֶׁל יִשְׂרָאֵל.

The Gemara attempts to bring proof for Rav Huna’s opinion from that which we learned in the mishna here: In a case where a Jew took a funnel and measured wine into a gentile’s jug, and then measured wine with the same funnel into a Jew’s jug,

אִם יֵשׁ בּוֹ עַכֶּבֶת יַיִן — אָסוּר. הָא עַכֶּבֶת יַיִן בְּמַאי קָא מִתַּסְרָא? לָאו בְּנִצּוֹק? שְׁמַע מִינַּהּ: נִצּוֹק חִיבּוּר.

if there is a remnant of wine left in the funnel, it is rendered forbidden. In what manner is this remnant of wine rendered forbidden? Is it not by the stream of wine going down from the funnel into the gentile’s vessel, thereby connecting the gentile’s vessel and the funnel and rendering the wine in the funnel forbidden? Conclude from it that a stream constitutes a connection.

תָּנֵי רַבִּי חִיָּיא: שֶׁפְּחָסַתּוּ צְלוֹחִיתוֹ, אֲבָל לֹא פְּחָסַתּוּ צְלוֹחִיתוֹ — מַאי? לָא, תִּפְשׁוֹט דְּנִצּוֹק אֵינוֹ חִיבּוּר! לָא, פְּחָסַתּוּ צְלוֹחִיתוֹ — תִּפְשׁוֹט לָךְ דְּאָסוּר, נִצּוֹק — תִּיבְּעֵי.

Rabbi Ḥiyya teaches that the mishna is referring to a situation where the wine in the gentile’s jug rose and reached the funnel. The Gemara infers: But in a case where the wine in the jug did not rise and reach the funnel, what is the halakha? It is not forbidden. Therefore, resolve the dilemma and conclude that a stream is not a connection. The Gemara rejects this inference: No, Rabbi Ḥiyya means to say that in a case where the wine in the jug rose and reached the funnel you can resolve the dilemma and conclude that it is forbidden, but with regard to a stream the dilemma remains unresolved.

תָּא שְׁמַע: הַמְעָרֶה מִכְּלִי לִכְלִי, אֶת שֶׁמְּעָרֶה מִמֶּנּוּ — מוּתָּר, הָא דְּבֵינֵי בֵּינֵי — אָסוּר. שְׁמַע מִינַּהּ: נִצּוֹק חִיבּוּר.

The Gemara suggests: Come and hear a proof from the second topic discussed in the mishna: In the case of one who pours wine from one vessel into another vessel, the wine left in the vessel from which he poured is permitted. The Gemara infers: But the stream of wine between the two vessels is forbidden. Conclude from it that a stream constitutes a connection.

אִי נִצּוֹק חִיבּוּר, אֲפִילּוּ דְּגַוֵּיהּ דְּמָנָא נָמֵי לִיתְּסַר! הָא לָא קַשְׁיָא, דְּקָא מְקַטֵּיף קַטּוֹפֵי. מִכׇּל מָקוֹם, נִצּוֹק חִיבּוּר!

The Gemara raises an objection to this proof: If a stream constitutes a connection, even the wine inside the vessel being poured from should also be forbidden. The Gemara responds to this objection: This is not difficult. It is the case where the one pouring the wine interrupts the flow, so the reason the wine in the vessel being poured from is permitted is that the stream is interrupted; but in any case, a stream is considered a connection.

וּלְטַעְמָיךְ, אֵימָא סֵיפָא: אֶת שֶׁעֵירָה לְתוֹכוֹ הוּא דַּאֲסִיר, הָא דְּבֵינֵי בֵּינֵי שְׁרֵי! אֶלָּא, מֵהָא לֵיכָּא לְמִשְׁמַע מִינַּהּ.

The Gemara rejects the proof: According to your reasoning, say that there is an inference from the latter clause of the mishna: It is the wine in the vessel into which he poured that is forbidden due to the forbidden remnant of wine in the funnel, but by inference, the stream of wine between the two vessels is permitted, contrary to the conclusion from the previous clause. Rather, no inference is to be learned from this mishna.

תָּא שְׁמַע: הַמְעָרֶה מֵחָבִית לַבּוֹר, קִילּוּחַ הַיּוֹרֵד מִשְּׂפַת חָבִית לְמַטָּה — אָסוּר! תַּרְגְּמַהּ רַב שֵׁשֶׁת: בְּגוֹי הַמְעָרֶה, דְּאָתֵי מִכֹּחוֹ.

The Gemara suggests: Come and hear another proof from a baraita: In the case of one who pours wine from a barrel into a wine cistern containing forbidden wine, the stream of wine coming from the rim of the barrel downward is rendered forbidden. Evidently, a stream constitutes a connection. Rav Sheshet interpreted this baraita as referring to a gentile pouring the wine from the barrel into the cistern, and the wine streaming out of the barrel is rendered forbidden because it came from the gentile’s force, i.e., the stream was powered by the gentile’s action. If a gentile moves wine, the wine is forbidden, even if the gentile did not touch it. The stream is not rendered forbidden by virtue of its connection to the wine in the cistern.

אִי גּוֹי הַמְעָרֶה, אֲפִילּוּ גַּוָּא דְּחָבִיתָא נָמֵי מִתְּסַר! כֹּחַ דְּגוֹי מִדְּרַבָּנַן הוּא דַּאֲסִיר, הַהוּא דִּנְפַק לְבָרַאי — גְּזַרוּ בֵּיהּ רַבָּנַן, הַהוּא דִּלְגַוַּאי — לָא גְּזַרוּ בֵּיהּ רַבָּנַן.

The Gemara raises an objection to this interpretation: If the reference is to a gentile who pours the wine, even the wine inside the barrel is rendered forbidden, because the gentile is also powering the movement of the barrel itself. The Gemara responds to this objection: The halakha that a gentile’s force renders wine forbidden is by rabbinic law. With regard to the wine that is poured out of the barrel, the Sages decreed that it is forbidden; but with regard to the wine that remains inside the barrel, the Sages did not decree that it is forbidden.

אֲמַר לְהוּ רַב חִסְדָּא לְהָנְהוּ סָבֹיָתָא: כִּי כָיְילִיתוּ חַמְרָא לְגוֹיִם — (קָטְפִי) [קַטִּיפוּ] קַטּוֹפֵי, אִי נָמֵי (נָפְצִי) [נַפִּיצוּ] נַפּוֹצֵי. אֲמַר לְהוּ רָבָא לְהָנְהוּ שָׁפוֹכָאֵי: כִּי שָׁפְכִיתוּ חַמְרָא — לָא לִיקְרַב גּוֹי לְסַיַּיע בַּהֲדַיְיכוּ, דִּלְמָא מִשְׁתְּלִיתוּ וְשָׁדֵיתוּ לֵיהּ עֲלֵיהּ, וְקָאָתֵי מִכֹּחוֹ וַאֲסִיר.

The Gemara relates accounts of how the Sages ruled concerning this matter: Rav Ḥisda said to certain wine retailers: When you measure wine for gentiles, pour with interruptions, rather than in a smooth steady stream, or toss it out in a single action that does not create a steady stream. Rava said to certain wine pourers: When you pour wine, do not let a gentile approach to help you, lest you let your guard down and rest the vessel in the gentile’s hands, and the wine will emerge due to his force and will be rendered forbidden.

הָהוּא גַּבְרָא דְּאַסֵּיק חַמְרָא בְּגִישְׁתָּא וּבַת גִּישְׁתָּא, אֲתָא גּוֹי אַנַּח יְדֵיהּ אַגִּישְׁתָּא, אַסְרֵיהּ רָבָא לְכוּלֵּיהּ חַמְרָא.

The Gemara relates: There was an incident involving a certain man who siphoned wine from a barrel with a large tube and a small tube. A gentile came and rested his hand upon the large tube. Rava deemed the entire quantity of wine forbidden, including the wine that was still in the barrel.

אֲמַר לֵיהּ רַב פָּפָּא לְרָבָא, וְאָמְרִי לַהּ רַב אַדָּא בַּר מַתְנָה לְרָבָא, וְאָמְרִי לַהּ רָבִינָא לְרָבָא: בְּמַאי? בְּנִצּוֹק. שָׁמְעַתְּ מִינַּהּ נִצּוֹק חִיבּוּר? שָׁאנֵי הָתָם, דְּכוּלֵּי חַמְרָא אַגִּישְׁתָּא וּבַת גִּישְׁתָּא גְּרִיר.

Rav Pappa said to Rava, and some say it was Rav Adda bar Mattana who said this to Rava, and some say it was Ravina who said this to Rava: By what mechanism was the wine rendered forbidden? Was it by the stream of wine that went through the large tube, which was rendered forbidden by the contact of the gentile, and the rest of the barrel was rendered forbidden by the connection with that stream? Should one conclude from this ruling that a stream constitutes a connection? Rava rejects this inference: It is different there, as all of the wine in the barrel is drawn toward the large tube and the small tube, and so it is as though the gentile had touched all of the wine in the barrel.

אָמַר מָר זוּטְרָא בְּרֵיהּ דְּרַב נַחְמָן: קְנִישְׁקְנִין שְׁרֵי, וְהָנֵי מִילֵּי דִּקְדֵים פְּסַק יִשְׂרָאֵל, אֲבָל קְדֵם פְּסַק גּוֹי — לָא. רַבָּה בַּר רַב הוּנָא אִיקְּלַע לְבֵי רֵישׁ גָּלוּתָא, שְׁרָא לְהוּ לְמִשְׁתֵּא בִּקְנִישְׁקְנִין.

Mar Zutra, son of Rav Naḥman, says: For a Jew and a gentile to drink simultaneously from a vessel with tubes for several people to drink from [kenishkanin] is permitted. And this statement applies only in a case where the Jew stops drinking first, before the gentile; but if the gentile stops drinking first, it does not apply and the wine is forbidden, as wine from the gentile’s mouth returns to the vessel and renders all of the wine forbidden. Rabba bar Rav Huna happened to come to the house of the Exilarch, and he permitted them to drink from a kenishkanin together with gentiles.

Today’s daily daf tools:

Delve Deeper

Broaden your understanding of the topics on this daf with classes and podcasts from top women Talmud scholars.

For the Beyond the Daf shiurim offered in Hebrew, see here.

New to Talmud?

Check out our resources designed to help you navigate a page of Talmud – and study at the pace, level and style that fits you. 

The Hadran Women’s Tapestry

Meet the diverse women learning Gemara at Hadran and hear their stories. 

Studying has changed my life view on הלכה and יהדות and time. It has taught me bonudaries of the human nature and honesty of our sages in their discourse to try and build a nation of caring people .

Goldie Gilad
Goldie Gilad

Kfar Saba, Israel

I started the daf at the beginning of this cycle in January 2020. My husband, my children, grandchildren and siblings have been very supportive. As someone who learned and taught Tanach and mefarshim for many years, it has been an amazing adventure to complete the six sedarim of Mishnah, and now to study Talmud on a daily basis along with Rabbanit Michelle and the wonderful women of Hadran.

Rookie Billet
Rookie Billet

Jerusalem, Israel

When I began the previous cycle, I promised myself that if I stuck with it, I would reward myself with a trip to Israel. Little did I know that the trip would involve attending the first ever women’s siyum and being inspired by so many learners. I am now over 2 years into my second cycle and being part of this large, diverse, fascinating learning family has enhanced my learning exponentially.

Shira Krebs
Shira Krebs

Minnesota, United States

I decided to learn one masechet, Brachot, but quickly fell in love and never stopped! It has been great, everyone is always asking how it’s going and chering me on, and my students are always making sure I did the day’s daf.

Yafit Fishbach
Yafit Fishbach

Memphis, Tennessee, United States

It has been a pleasure keeping pace with this wonderful and scholarly group of women.

Janice Block
Janice Block

Beit Shemesh, Israel

3 years ago, I joined Rabbanit Michelle to organize the unprecedented Siyum HaShas event in Jerusalem for thousands of women. The whole experience was so inspiring that I decided then to start learning the daf and see how I would go…. and I’m still at it. I often listen to the Daf on my bike in mornings, surrounded by both the external & the internal beauty of Eretz Yisrael & Am Yisrael!

Lisa Kolodny
Lisa Kolodny

Raanana, Israel

Inspired by Hadran’s first Siyum ha Shas L’Nashim two years ago, I began daf yomi right after for the next cycle. As to this extraordinary journey together with Hadran..as TS Eliot wrote “We must not cease from exploration and the end of all our exploring will be to arrive where we began and to know the place for the first time.

Susan Handelman
Susan Handelman

Jerusalem, Israel

I started Daf during the pandemic. I listened to a number of podcasts by various Rebbeim until one day, I discovered Rabbanit Farbers podcast. Subsequently I joined the Hadran family in Eruvin. Not the easiest place to begin, Rabbanit Farber made it all understandable and fun. The online live group has bonded together and have really become a supportive, encouraging family.

Leah Goldford
Leah Goldford

Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

I began learning with Rabbanit Michelle’s wonderful Talmud Skills class on Pesachim, which really enriched my Pesach seder, and I have been learning Daf Yomi off and on over the past year. Because I’m relatively new at this, there is a “chiddush” for me every time I learn, and the knowledge and insights of the group members add so much to my experience. I feel very lucky to be a part of this.

Julie-Landau-Photo
Julie Landau

Karmiel, Israel

I was moved to tears by the Hadran Siyyum HaShas. I have learned Torah all my life, but never connected to learning Gemara on a regular basis until then. Seeing the sheer joy Talmud Torah at the siyyum, I felt compelled to be part of it, and I haven’t missed a day!
It’s not always easy, but it is so worthwhile, and it has strengthened my love of learning. It is part of my life now.

Michelle Lewis
Michelle Lewis

Beit Shemesh, Israel

Ive been learning Gmara since 5th grade and always loved it. Have always wanted to do Daf Yomi and now with Michelle Farber’s online classes it made it much easier to do! Really enjoying the experience thank you!!

Lisa Lawrence
Lisa Lawrence

Neve Daniel, Israel

I’ve been studying Talmud since the ’90s, and decided to take on Daf Yomi two years ago. I wanted to attempt the challenge of a day-to-day, very Jewish activity. Some days are so interesting and some days are so boring. But I’m still here.
Sarene Shanus
Sarene Shanus

Mamaroneck, NY, United States

After reading the book, “ If All The Seas Were Ink “ by Ileana Kurshan I started studying Talmud. I searched and studied with several teachers until I found Michelle Farber. I have been studying with her for two years. I look forward every day to learn from her.

Janine Rubens
Janine Rubens

Virginia, United States

I started learning daf in January, 2020, being inspired by watching the Siyyum Hashas in Binyanei Haumah. I wasn’t sure I would be able to keep up with the task. When I went to school, Gemara was not an option. Fast forward to March, 2022, and each day starts with the daf. The challenge is now learning the intricacies of delving into the actual learning. Hadran community, thank you!

Rochel Cheifetz
Rochel Cheifetz

Riverdale, NY, United States

After being so inspired by the siyum shas two years ago, I began tentatively learning daf yomi, like Rabbanut Michelle kept saying – taking one daf at a time. I’m still taking it one daf at a time, one masechet at a time, but I’m loving it and am still so inspired by Rabbanit Michelle and the Hadran community, and yes – I am proud to be finishing Seder Mo’ed.

Caroline Graham-Ofstein
Caroline Graham-Ofstein

Bet Shemesh, Israel

Geri Goldstein got me started learning daf yomi when I was in Israel 2 years ago. It’s been a challenge and I’ve learned a lot though I’m sure I miss a lot. I quilt as I listen and I want to share what I’ve been working on.

Rebecca Stulberg
Rebecca Stulberg

Ottawa, Canada

Studying has changed my life view on הלכה and יהדות and time. It has taught me bonudaries of the human nature and honesty of our sages in their discourse to try and build a nation of caring people .

Goldie Gilad
Goldie Gilad

Kfar Saba, Israel

Years ago, I attended the local Siyum HaShas with my high school class. It was inspiring! Through that cycle and the next one, I studied masekhtot on my own and then did “daf yomi practice.” The amazing Hadran Siyum HaShas event firmed my resolve to “really do” Daf Yomi this time. It has become a family goal. We’ve supported each other through challenges, and now we’re at the Siyum of Seder Moed!

Elisheva Brauner
Elisheva Brauner

Jerusalem, Israel

I started learning after the siyum hashas for women and my daily learning has been a constant over the last two years. It grounded me during the chaos of Corona while providing me with a community of fellow learners. The Daf can be challenging but it’s filled with life’s lessons, struggles and hope for a better world. It’s not about the destination but rather about the journey. Thank you Hadran!

Dena Lehrman
Dena Lehrman

אפרת, Israel

I began Daf Yomi with the last cycle. I was inspired by the Hadran Siyum in Yerushalayim to continue with this cycle. I have learned Daf Yomi with Rabanit Michelle in over 25 countries on 6 continents ( missing Australia)

Barbara-Goldschlag
Barbara Goldschlag

Silver Spring, MD, United States

Avodah Zarah 72

Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ·ΧΧ™ ״לֹא Χ Φ΄Χ™Χͺַּן ΧœΦ°Χ”Φ΄Χ™Χ©ΦΌΧΦΈΧ‘Χ•ΦΉΧŸΧ΄? דְּא֡ינוֹ Χ‘ΦΌΦ°ΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧ¨Φ·Χͺ Χ”Φ΄Χ™Χ©ΦΌΧΦΈΧ‘Χ•ΦΉΧŸ.

And what does it mean that the stolen object is not subject to restitution? It means that it is not subject to the halakhot of restitution, because it is not technically a theft.

אִי Χ”ΦΈΧ›Φ΄Χ™, ΧΦ΅Χ™ΧžΦΈΧ ב֡י׀ָא: בָּא Χ—Φ²Χ‘Φ΅Χ™Χ¨Χ•ΦΉ Χ•ΦΌΧ Φ°Χ˜ΦΈΧœΦΈΧ”ΦΌ ΧžΦ΄ΧžΦΌΦΆΧ ΦΌΧ•ΦΌ β€” Χ ΦΆΧ”Φ±Χ¨ΦΈΧ’ Χ’ΦΈΧœΦΆΧ™Χ”ΦΈ. Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄Χ©ΧΦ°ΧœΦΈΧžΦΈΧ ר֡ישָׁא, ΧžΦ΄Χ©ΦΌΧΧ•ΦΌΧ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ¦Φ·Χ’Φ²Χ¨Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ ΧœΦ°Χ™Φ΄Χ©Χ‚Φ°Χ¨ΦΈΧΦ΅Χœ, א֢לָּא ב֡י׀ָא, ΧžΦ·ΧΧ™ Χ’ΦΈΧ‘Φ΅Χ™Χ“?

The Gemara asks: If that is so, say the latter clause of that halakhic statement: If another descendant of Noah came and took the stolen item from him, he is also executed for it. Granted, with regard to the first clause it can be explained that although there is no obligation to return the item, the gentile is executed because he caused the Jew distress; but with regard to the latter clause, what did he do? He did not cause the Jew distress, and since the item is worth less than one peruta, one is not obligated to return it unless he stole it from a gentile. Consequently, the second theft should not be considered a legally significant act.

א֢לָּא שְׁמַג ΧžΦ΄Χ™Χ ΦΌΦ·Χ”ΦΌ, ΧžΦ°Χ©ΧΦ΄Χ™Χ›ΦΈΧ” Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ’Χ•ΦΉΧ™ Χ§Χ•ΦΉΧ ΦΈΧ”, שְׁמַג ΧžΦ΄Χ™Χ ΦΌΦ·Χ”ΦΌ.

Rather, should one not conclude from it that one pulling an item acquires it in a transaction performed by a gentile? Accordingly, the actions of both the first and second gentiles are legally significant acts of theft, for which they are liable to be executed. The Gemara affirms: Conclude from it that this is so.

הָהוּא גַּבְרָא Χ“ΦΌΦ·ΧΦ²ΧžΦ·Χ¨ ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ ΧœΦ°Χ—Φ·Χ‘Φ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ: ״אִי ΧžΦ°Χ–Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ Φ°Χ ΦΈΧ ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ ΧœΦ°Χ”ΦΈΧ אַרְגָא β€” לָךְ ΧžΦ°Χ–Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ Φ°Χ ΦΈΧ ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌΧ΄, ΧΦ²Χ–Φ·Χœ Χ–Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ Φ·Χ”ΦΌ ΧœΦ°ΧΦ΄Χ™Χ Φ΄Χ™Χ©Χ אַחֲרִינָא, אֲמַר Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ Χ™Χ•ΦΉΧ‘Φ΅Χ£: Χ§Φ°Χ ΦΈΧ” קַמָּא.

Β§ The Gemara relates: There was an incident involving a certain man who said to another: If I sell this land, I will sell it to you, and they performed a formal act of acquisition to ratify the agreement. He went and sold it to another person. Rav Yosef said: The first one has acquired it.

אֲמַר ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ אַבָּי֡י: וְהָא לָא Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ·Χ§! Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°Χ ΦΈΧ ΧͺΦΌΦ΅Χ™ΧžΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ›ΦΉΧœ ה֡יכָא Χ“ΦΌΦ°ΧœΦΈΧ Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ·Χ§ לָא Χ§Φ°Χ ΦΈΧ”? Χ“ΦΌΦ΄Χͺְנַן: Χ”Φ·ΧžΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ›Φ΅Χ¨ Χ™Φ΅Χ™Χ Χ•ΦΉ ΧœΦ°Χ Χ‡Χ›Φ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™, Χ€ΦΌΦΈΧ‘Φ·Χ§ Χ’Φ·Χ“ שׁ֢לֹּא ΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ β€” Χ“ΦΌΦΈΧžΦΈΧ™Χ• ΧžΧ•ΦΌΧͺΦΌΦΈΧ¨Φ΄Χ™ΧŸ, ΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ Χ’Φ·Χ“ שׁ֢לֹּא Χ€ΦΌΦΈΧ‘Φ·Χ§ β€” Χ“ΦΌΦΈΧžΦΈΧ™Χ• ΧΦ²Χ‘Χ•ΦΌΧ¨Φ΄Χ™ΧŸ.

Abaye said to him: But he did not fix a price with him for it. And from where do you say that wherever the people involved in the transaction did not fix a price, the buyer has not acquired the item, even if they performed a formal act of acquisition? It is from that which we learned in the mishna: In the case of a Jew who sells his wine to a gentile, if he fixed a price before he measured the wine into the gentile’s vessel, deriving benefit from the money paid for the wine is permitted. But if the Jew measured the wine into the gentile’s vessel, thereby rendering it forbidden, before he fixed a price, the money paid for the wine is forbidden.

ΧžΦ·ΧΧ™ Χ”ΦΈΧ•Φ΅Χ™ Χ’Φ²ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ? ΧžΦ·ΧΧ™ Χ”ΦΈΧ•Φ΅Χ™ Χ’Φ²ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ?! Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ“Φ°Χ§ΦΈΧΦΈΧžΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™Χ Φ·ΧŸ! Χ“ΦΌΦ΄ΧœΦ°ΧžΦΈΧ Χ—Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ™Φ΅Χ™ΧŸ נ֢ב֢ךְ שָׁאנ֡י.

The Gemara asks: What halakhic conclusion was reached about this matter? The Gemara interjects: What is meant by the question: What halakhic conclusion was reached about this matter? The conclusion is as we have stated, that it is evident from the mishna that the acquisition goes into effect only after the price is fixed. The Gemara explains its question: Perhaps due to the stringency of the prohibition of wine used for a libation, the case of the mishna is different and is not characteristic of the halakha in monetary matters.

Χͺָּא שְׁמַג, Χ“ΦΌΦ°ΧΦΈΧžΦ·Χ¨ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ אִידִי Χ‘ΦΌΦ·Χ¨ ΧΦΈΧ‘Φ΄Χ™ΧŸ: גוֹבָדָא Χ”Φ²Χ•ΦΈΧ” Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ חִבְדָּא, Χ•Φ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ חִבְדָּא Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ הוּנָא, Χ•ΦΌΧ€Φ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ˜Φ»Χ™Χ”ΦΈ ΧžΦ΅Χ”ΦΈΧ Χ“ΦΌΦ΄Χͺְנַן: מָשַׁךְ Χ—Φ²ΧžΦΈΧ¨ΦΈΧ™Χ• Χ•ΦΌΧ€Χ•ΦΉΧ’Φ²ΧœΦΈΧ™Χ• Χ•Φ°Χ”Φ΄Χ›Φ°Χ Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΈΧŸ לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧšΦ° Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ, Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™ΧŸ Χ€ΦΌΦΈΧ‘Φ·Χ§ Χ’Φ·Χ“ שׁ֢לֹּא ΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ Χ•ΦΌΧ‘Φ΅Χ™ΧŸ ΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ Χ’Φ·Χ“ שׁ֢לֹּא Χ€ΦΌΦΈΧ‘Φ·Χ§ β€” לֹא Χ§ΦΈΧ ΦΈΧ”, Χ•ΦΌΧ©ΧΦ°Χ Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΆΧŸ Χ™Φ°Χ›Χ•ΦΉΧœΦ΄Χ™ΧŸ ΧœΦ·Χ—Φ²Χ–Χ•ΦΉΧ¨ Χ‘ΦΌΦΈΧ”ΦΆΧŸ.

The Gemara suggests: Come and hear a proof that an acquisition goes into effect only after the price is fixed, as Rav Idi bar Avin said: There was an incident that came before the school of Rav αΈ€isda, and Rav αΈ€isda brought it before the school of Rav Huna, and Rav Huna resolved it from that which we learned in a baraita: If one bought from another produce that was loaded on the seller’s donkeys or carried by his laborers, and the purchaser drew the seller’s donkey drivers or laborers laden with produce and brought them into his house, in this case, whether the seller fixed a price before he measured the produce or whether he measured the produce before he fixed a price, the purchaser has not acquired the produce, and both of them, the purchaser or the seller, can retract the transaction, as no act of acquisition took place.

׀ּ֡רְקָן Χ•Φ°Χ”Φ΄Χ›Φ°Χ Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΈΧŸ לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧšΦ° Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ, Χ€ΦΌΦΈΧ‘Φ·Χ§ Χ’Φ·Χ“ שׁ֢לֹּא ΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ β€” ΧΦ΅Χ™ΧŸ Χ©ΧΦ°Χ Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΆΧŸ Χ™Φ°Χ›Χ•ΦΉΧœΦ΄Χ™ΧŸ ΧœΦ·Χ—Φ²Χ–Χ•ΦΉΧ¨ Χ‘ΦΌΦΈΧ”ΦΆΧŸ, ΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ Χ’Φ·Χ“ שׁ֢לֹּא Χ€ΦΌΦΈΧ‘Φ·Χ§ β€” Χ©ΧΦ°Χ Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΆΧŸ Χ™Φ°Χ›Χ•ΦΉΧœΦ΄Χ™ΧŸ ΧœΦ·Χ—Φ²Χ–Χ•ΦΉΧ¨ Χ‘ΦΌΦΈΧ”ΦΆΧŸ.

The baraita continues: But if the purchaser unloaded the produce and brought it into his house, this constitutes an act of acquisition, and therefore if he fixed a price before he measured the produce, neither of them can retract, but if he measured the produce before he fixed a price, both of them can retract. This illustrates that even if there was an act of acquisition, they can retract the transaction until the price has been fixed, in accordance with the statement of Abaye.

הָהוּא גַּבְרָא Χ“ΦΌΦ·ΧΦ²ΧžΦ·Χ¨ ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ ΧœΦ°Χ—Φ·Χ‘Φ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ: ״אִי ΧžΦ°Χ–Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ Φ°Χ ΦΈΧ ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ ΧœΦ°Χ”ΦΈΧ אַרְגָא β€” ΧžΦ°Χ–Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ Φ°Χ ΦΈΧ לָךְ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄ΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ–Χ•ΦΌΧ–Φ΅Χ™Χ΄, ΧΦ²Χ–Φ·Χœ Χ–Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ Φ·Χ”ΦΌ ΧœΦ°ΧΦ΄Χ™Χ Φ΄Χ™Χ©Χ אַחֲרִינָא Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄ΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ•Φ°Χ’ΦΆΧ©Χ‚Φ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™ΧŸ. אָמַר Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ כָּהֲנָא: Χ§Φ°Χ ΦΈΧ” קַמָּא. מַΧͺΦ°Χ§Φ΅Χ™Χ£ ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ Χ™Φ·Χ’Φ²Χ§ΦΉΧ‘ ΧžΦ΄Χ ΦΌΦ°Χ”Φ·Χ¨ Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ§Χ•ΦΉΧ“: הַאי Χ–Χ•ΦΌΧ–Φ΅Χ™ אַנְבוּהּ! Χ•Φ°Χ”Φ΄ΧœΦ°Χ›Φ°Χͺָא Χ›ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ Χ™Φ·Χ’Φ²Χ§ΦΉΧ‘ ΧžΦ΄Χ ΦΌΦ°Χ”Φ·Χ¨ Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ§Χ•ΦΉΧ“.

Β§ There was a related incident involving a certain man who said to another: If I will desire to sell this land, I will sell it to you for one hundred dinars, and they performed an act of acquisition to ratify the agreement. He went and sold it to another person for one hundred and twenty dinars. Rav Kahana said: The first one has acquired it. Rav Ya’akov of Nehar Pekod objects to this: Those twenty additional dinars compelled him to sell it to the second purchaser. The Gemara concludes: And the halakha is in accordance with the opinion of Rav Ya’akov of Nehar Pekod.

אֲמַר ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ΄Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ“Φ°Χ©ΧΦΈΧ™Φ°Χ™ΧžΦ΄Χ™ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄ΧͺְלָΧͺָא״ β€” ΧΦ²Χ€Φ΄Χ™ΧœΦΌΧ•ΦΌ ΧͺΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ™ ΧžΦ΄Χ’ΦΌΧ•ΦΉ ΧͺְּלָΧͺָא. Χ΄Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ“Φ°ΧΦΈΧžΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄ΧͺְלָΧͺָא״ β€” Χ’Φ·Χ“ Χ“ΦΌΦ°ΧΦΈΧžΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄ΧͺְלָΧͺָא. Χ΄Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ“Φ°Χ©ΧΦΈΧ™Φ°Χ™ΧžΦ΄Χ™ בְּאַרְבְּגָה״ β€” Χ’Φ·Χ“ Χ“ΦΌΦ°ΧΦΈΧžΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™ בְּאַרְבָּגָה, Χ•Φ°Χ›Χ‡Χœ Χ©ΧΦΆΧ›ΦΌΦ΅ΧŸ ה֡יכָא Χ“ΦΌΦ·ΧΦ²ΧžΦ·Χ¨ ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ΄Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ“Φ°ΧΦΈΧžΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™ בְּאַרְבָּגָה״.

Β§ If the seller said to the purchaser: I will sell you this merchandise as it is assessed by three people, even if two out of the three agreed to a certain assessment, the seller must accept this price. If he said: I will sell you this merchandise in accordance with the price that is stated by three people, he is not held to their assessment unless it is stated by all three. If he said: As it is assessed by four people, he is not held to their assessment unless it is stated by all four; and all the more so in a case where he said to him: In accordance with the price that is stated by four people.

אֲמַר ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ: Χ΄Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ“Φ°Χ©ΧΦΈΧ™Φ°Χ™ΧžΦ΄Χ™ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄ΧͺְלָΧͺָא״, וַאֲΧͺΧ•ΦΉ ΧͺְּלָΧͺָא Χ•Φ°Χ©ΧΦΈΧžΧ•ΦΌΧ”ΦΈ, Χ•Φ·ΧΦ²ΧžΦ·Χ¨ ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ ΧΦ΄Χ™Χ“ΦΌΦ·ΧšΦ°: ΧœΦ΅Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ ΧͺְּלָΧͺָא אַחֲרִינ֡י דְּקִים ΧœΦ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ Χ˜Φ°Χ€Φ΅Χ™! אָמַר Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ ׀ָּ׀ָּא: דִּינָא הוּא Χ“ΦΌΦ΄ΧžΦ°Χ’Φ·Χ›ΦΌΦ΅Χ‘. מַΧͺΦ°Χ§Φ΅Χ™Χ£ ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ הוּנָא Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ יְהוֹשֻׁגַ: ΧžΦ΄ΧžΦΌΦ·ΧΧ™ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ”ΦΈΧ Φ΅Χ™ קִים ΧœΦ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ Χ˜Φ°Χ€Φ΅Χ™? Χ“ΦΌΦ΄ΧœΦ°ΧžΦΈΧ Χ”ΦΈΧ Φ΅Χ™ קִים ΧœΦ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ Χ˜Φ°Χ€Φ΅Χ™! Χ•Φ°Χ”Φ΄ΧœΦ°Χ›Φ°Χͺָא Χ›ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ הוּנָא Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ יְהוֹשֻׁגַ.

If the seller said to the buyer: I will sell you this merchandise as it is assessed by three people, and three people came and assessed it, and the other one, the purchaser, said: Let three other people, who are more proficient in their assessment, come and assess the merchandise, Rav Pappa said: The halakha is that he can prevent the price from being set until more proficient people assess the merchandise. Rav Huna, son of Rav Yehoshua, objects to this: From where can he know that those other three are more proficient in their assessment? Perhaps these, the first three, are more proficient. The Gemara concludes: And the halakha is in accordance with the opinion of Rav Huna, son of Rav Yehoshua.

מַΧͺΦ°Χ Φ΄Χ™Χ³ נָטַל א֢Χͺ Χ”Φ·ΧžΦΌΦ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ€ΦΌΦ΅ΧšΦ° Χ•ΦΌΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧšΦ° Χ¦Φ°ΧœΧ•ΦΉΧ—Φ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ שׁ֢ל Χ Χ‡Χ›Φ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™, Χ•Φ°Χ—ΦΈΧ–Φ·Χ¨ Χ•ΦΌΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧšΦ° Χ¦Φ°ΧœΧ•ΦΉΧ—Φ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ שׁ֢ל Χ™Φ΄Χ©Χ‚Φ°Χ¨ΦΈΧΦ΅Χœ, אִם י֡שׁ Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΉ Χ’Φ·Χ›ΦΌΦΆΧ‘ΦΆΧͺ Χ™Φ·Χ™Φ΄ΧŸ β€” אָבוּר. Χ”Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ’ΦΈΧ¨ΦΆΧ” ΧžΦ΄Χ›ΦΌΦ°ΧœΦ΄Χ™ א֢ל Χ›ΦΌΦ°ΧœΦ΄Χ™, א֢Χͺ שׁ֢ג֡ירָה ΧžΦ΄ΧžΦΌΦΆΧ ΦΌΧ•ΦΌ β€” ΧžΧ•ΦΌΧͺΦΌΦΈΧ¨, וְא֢Χͺ שׁ֢ג֡ירָה לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧ›Χ•ΦΉ β€” אָבוּר.

MISHNA: In a case where a Jew took a funnel and measured wine into a gentile’s jug, and then measured wine with the same funnel into a Jew’s jug, if there is a remnant of wine left in the funnel, the wine measured into the Jew’s jug is forbidden, as some of the wine that was measured into the gentile’s jug is mixed in it. In the case of one who pours wine from one vessel into another vessel, the wine left in the vessel from which he poured is permitted, but the wine in the vessel into which he poured is forbidden.

Χ’ΦΌΦ°ΧžΦΈΧ³ Χͺְּנַן Χ”ΦΈΧͺָם: Χ”Φ·Χ ΦΌΦ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§, Χ•Φ°Χ”Φ·Χ§ΦΌΦΈΧ˜Φ·Χ€Φ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ‘, Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ§ΦΆΧ” Χ˜Χ•ΦΉΧ€Φ΅Χ—Φ· β€” א֡ינוֹ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨, לֹא ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ•Φ°ΧœΦΉΧ ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ‡Χ”Φ³Χ¨ΦΈΧ”. Χ”ΦΈΧΦ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ¨ΦΆΧŸ β€” Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨ ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ•ΦΌΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ‡Χ”Φ³Χ¨ΦΈΧ”.

GEMARA: We learned in a mishna elsewhere (Teharot 8:9): A stream of water, and water descending an incline [vehakatafres], and liquid that rendered an item moist do not constitute a connection between liquids, neither with regard to ritual impurity nor with regard to purity. These liquids do not constitute a connection that transmits impurity, e.g., if impure water is in one place and becomes attached to water above it, the water above is not considered attached to the impure water and is not rendered impure. They also do not constitute a connection for purification, e.g., if two collections of water are attached via the pouring of a stream, they do not join together to form the amount of water necessary to form a valid ritual bath, through which people and items can become ritually pure. A pond constitutes a connection between liquids with regard to impurity and with regard to purity.

אָמַר Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ הוּנָא: Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ Χ•Φ°Χ§ΦΈΧ˜Φ·Χ€Φ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ‘ Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ§ΦΆΧ” Χ˜Χ•ΦΉΧ€Φ΅Χ—Φ· Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨ ΧœΦ°Χ’Φ΄Χ Φ°Χ™Φ·ΧŸ Χ™Φ΅Χ™ΧŸ נ֢ב֢ךְ.

Rav Huna says: A stream of water, and water descending an incline, and liquid that rendered an item moist constitute a connection with regard to the matter of wine used for a libation.

אֲמַר ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ Χ Φ·Χ—Φ°ΧžΦΈΧŸ ΧœΦ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ הוּנָא: מְנָא לָךְ הָא? ΧΦ΄Χ™ΧœΦΌΦ΅Χ™ΧžΦΈΧ ΧžΦ΄Χ“ΦΌΦ΄Χͺְנַן: Χ”Φ·Χ ΦΌΦ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ Χ•Φ°Χ”Φ·Χ§ΦΌΦΈΧ˜Φ·Χ€Φ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ‘ Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ§ΦΆΧ” Χ˜Χ•ΦΉΧ€Φ΅Χ—Φ· א֡ינוֹ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨ לֹא ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ•Φ°ΧœΦΉΧ ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ‡Χ”Φ³Χ¨ΦΈΧ”, ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ•ΦΌΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ‡Χ”Φ³Χ¨ΦΈΧ” הוּא Χ“ΦΌΦ°ΧœΦΈΧ Χ”ΦΈΧ•Φ΅Χ™ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨, הָא ΧœΦ°Χ’Φ΄Χ Φ°Χ™Φ·ΧŸ Χ™Φ΅Χ™ΧŸ נ֢ב֢ךְ Χ”ΦΈΧ•Φ΅Χ™ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨ β€” ΧΦ΅Χ™ΧžΦΈΧ ב֡י׀ָא: Χ”ΦΈΧΦ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ¨ΦΆΧŸ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨ ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ•ΦΌΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ‡Χ”Φ³Χ¨ΦΈΧ”, ΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ•ΦΌΧžΦ°ΧΦΈΧ” Χ•ΦΌΧœΦ°Χ˜Χ‡Χ”Φ³Χ¨ΦΈΧ” הוּא Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ”ΦΈΧ•Φ΅Χ™ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨, הָא ΧœΦ°Χ’Φ΄Χ Φ°Χ™Φ·ΧŸ Χ™Φ΅Χ™ΧŸ נ֢ב֢ךְ לָא Χ”ΦΈΧ•Φ΅Χ™ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨. א֢לָּא ΧžΦ΅Χ”ΦΈΧ ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ›ΦΌΦΈΧ לְמִשְׁמַג ΧžΦ΄Χ™Χ ΦΌΦ·Χ”ΦΌ.

Rav NaαΈ₯man said to Rav Huna: From where do you derive this? If we say it is derived from that which we learned in the mishna: A stream, and water descending an incline, and liquid that rendered an item moist do not constitute a connection between liquids, neither with regard to ritual impurity nor with regard to purity, and it is inferred that it is with regard to impurity and with regard to purity that it does not constitute a connection, but with regard to wine used for a libation it does constitute a connection, then say the latter clause: A pond constitutes a connection between liquids with regard to impurity and with regard to purity. It can be inferred from here that with regard to impurity and with regard to purity it is a connection, but with regard to wine used for a libation it is not a connection, contrary to the halakha inferred from the former clause. Rather, clearly no inference is to be learned from this mishna.

Χͺְּנַן: נָטַל א֢Χͺ Χ”Φ·ΧžΦΌΦ·Χ©ΧΦ°Χ€ΦΌΦ΅ΧšΦ° Χ•ΦΌΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧšΦ° Χ¦Φ°ΧœΧ•ΦΉΧ—Φ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ שׁ֢ל Χ Χ‡Χ›Φ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™, Χ•Φ°Χ—ΦΈΧ–Φ·Χ¨ Χ•ΦΌΧžΦΈΧ“Φ·Χ“ לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧšΦ° Χ¦Φ°ΧœΧ•ΦΉΧ—Φ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ שׁ֢ל Χ™Φ΄Χ©Χ‚Φ°Χ¨ΦΈΧΦ΅Χœ.

The Gemara attempts to bring proof for Rav Huna’s opinion from that which we learned in the mishna here: In a case where a Jew took a funnel and measured wine into a gentile’s jug, and then measured wine with the same funnel into a Jew’s jug,

אִם י֡שׁ Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΉ Χ’Φ·Χ›ΦΌΦΆΧ‘ΦΆΧͺ Χ™Φ·Χ™Φ΄ΧŸ β€” אָבוּר. הָא Χ’Φ·Χ›ΦΌΦΆΧ‘ΦΆΧͺ Χ™Φ·Χ™Φ΄ΧŸ Χ‘ΦΌΦ°ΧžΦ·ΧΧ™ קָא מִΧͺַּבְרָא? ΧœΦΈΧΧ• Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§? שְׁמַג ΧžΦ΄Χ™Χ ΦΌΦ·Χ”ΦΌ: Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨.

if there is a remnant of wine left in the funnel, it is rendered forbidden. In what manner is this remnant of wine rendered forbidden? Is it not by the stream of wine going down from the funnel into the gentile’s vessel, thereby connecting the gentile’s vessel and the funnel and rendering the wine in the funnel forbidden? Conclude from it that a stream constitutes a connection.

ΧͺΦΌΦΈΧ Φ΅Χ™ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄Χ™ חִיָּיא: שׁ֢׀ְּחָבַΧͺΦΌΧ•ΦΌ Χ¦Φ°ΧœΧ•ΦΉΧ—Φ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ, ΧΦ²Χ‘ΦΈΧœ לֹא Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ—ΦΈΧ‘Φ·ΧͺΦΌΧ•ΦΌ Χ¦Φ°ΧœΧ•ΦΉΧ—Φ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ β€” ΧžΦ·ΧΧ™? לָא, ΧͺΦΌΦ΄Χ€Φ°Χ©ΧΧ•ΦΉΧ˜ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ א֡ינוֹ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨! לָא, Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ—ΦΈΧ‘Φ·ΧͺΦΌΧ•ΦΌ Χ¦Φ°ΧœΧ•ΦΉΧ—Φ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΉ β€” ΧͺΦΌΦ΄Χ€Φ°Χ©ΧΧ•ΦΉΧ˜ לָךְ דְּאָבוּר, Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ β€” ΧͺΦΌΦ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ’Φ΅Χ™.

Rabbi αΈ€iyya teaches that the mishna is referring to a situation where the wine in the gentile’s jug rose and reached the funnel. The Gemara infers: But in a case where the wine in the jug did not rise and reach the funnel, what is the halakha? It is not forbidden. Therefore, resolve the dilemma and conclude that a stream is not a connection. The Gemara rejects this inference: No, Rabbi αΈ€iyya means to say that in a case where the wine in the jug rose and reached the funnel you can resolve the dilemma and conclude that it is forbidden, but with regard to a stream the dilemma remains unresolved.

Χͺָּא שְׁמַג: Χ”Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ’ΦΈΧ¨ΦΆΧ” ΧžΦ΄Χ›ΦΌΦ°ΧœΦ΄Χ™ ΧœΦ΄Χ›Φ°ΧœΦ΄Χ™, א֢Χͺ Χ©ΧΦΆΧžΦΌΦ°Χ’ΦΈΧ¨ΦΆΧ” ΧžΦ΄ΧžΦΌΦΆΧ ΦΌΧ•ΦΌ β€” ΧžΧ•ΦΌΧͺΦΌΦΈΧ¨, הָא Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ΅Χ™Χ Φ΅Χ™ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ Φ΅Χ™ β€” אָבוּר. שְׁמַג ΧžΦ΄Χ™Χ ΦΌΦ·Χ”ΦΌ: Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨.

The Gemara suggests: Come and hear a proof from the second topic discussed in the mishna: In the case of one who pours wine from one vessel into another vessel, the wine left in the vessel from which he poured is permitted. The Gemara infers: But the stream of wine between the two vessels is forbidden. Conclude from it that a stream constitutes a connection.

אִי Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨, ΧΦ²Χ€Φ΄Χ™ΧœΦΌΧ•ΦΌ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ’Φ·Χ•ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ“ΦΌΦ°ΧžΦΈΧ ΦΈΧ Χ ΦΈΧžΦ΅Χ™ ΧœΦ΄Χ™ΧͺΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ·Χ¨! הָא לָא קַשְׁיָא, דְּקָא ΧžΦ°Χ§Φ·Χ˜ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ£ Χ§Φ·Χ˜ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ€Φ΅Χ™. ΧžΦ΄Χ›ΦΌΧ‡Χœ ΧžΦΈΧ§Χ•ΦΉΧ, Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨!

The Gemara raises an objection to this proof: If a stream constitutes a connection, even the wine inside the vessel being poured from should also be forbidden. The Gemara responds to this objection: This is not difficult. It is the case where the one pouring the wine interrupts the flow, so the reason the wine in the vessel being poured from is permitted is that the stream is interrupted; but in any case, a stream is considered a connection.

Χ•ΦΌΧœΦ°Χ˜Φ·Χ’Φ°ΧžΦΈΧ™ΧšΦ°, ΧΦ΅Χ™ΧžΦΈΧ ב֡י׀ָא: א֢Χͺ שׁ֢ג֡ירָה לְΧͺΧ•ΦΉΧ›Χ•ΦΉ הוּא דַּאֲבִיר, הָא Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ΅Χ™Χ Φ΅Χ™ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ Φ΅Χ™ שְׁר֡י! א֢לָּא, ΧžΦ΅Χ”ΦΈΧ ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ›ΦΌΦΈΧ לְמִשְׁמַג ΧžΦ΄Χ™Χ ΦΌΦ·Χ”ΦΌ.

The Gemara rejects the proof: According to your reasoning, say that there is an inference from the latter clause of the mishna: It is the wine in the vessel into which he poured that is forbidden due to the forbidden remnant of wine in the funnel, but by inference, the stream of wine between the two vessels is permitted, contrary to the conclusion from the previous clause. Rather, no inference is to be learned from this mishna.

Χͺָּא שְׁמַג: Χ”Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ’ΦΈΧ¨ΦΆΧ” ΧžΦ΅Χ—ΦΈΧ‘Φ΄Χ™Χͺ ΧœΦ·Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ¨, Χ§Φ΄Χ™ΧœΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ—Φ· Χ”Φ·Χ™ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ¨Φ΅Χ“ ΧžΦ΄Χ©ΦΌΧ‚Φ°Χ€Φ·Χͺ Χ—ΦΈΧ‘Φ΄Χ™Χͺ ΧœΦ°ΧžΦ·Χ˜ΦΌΦΈΧ” β€” אָבוּר! ΧͺΦΌΦ·Χ¨Φ°Χ’ΦΌΦ°ΧžΦ·Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ שׁ֡שׁ֢Χͺ: Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ’Χ•ΦΉΧ™ Χ”Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ’ΦΈΧ¨ΦΆΧ”, דְּאָΧͺΦ΅Χ™ ΧžΦ΄Χ›ΦΌΦΉΧ—Χ•ΦΉ.

The Gemara suggests: Come and hear another proof from a baraita: In the case of one who pours wine from a barrel into a wine cistern containing forbidden wine, the stream of wine coming from the rim of the barrel downward is rendered forbidden. Evidently, a stream constitutes a connection. Rav Sheshet interpreted this baraita as referring to a gentile pouring the wine from the barrel into the cistern, and the wine streaming out of the barrel is rendered forbidden because it came from the gentile’s force, i.e., the stream was powered by the gentile’s action. If a gentile moves wine, the wine is forbidden, even if the gentile did not touch it. The stream is not rendered forbidden by virtue of its connection to the wine in the cistern.

אִי Χ’ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ™ Χ”Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ’ΦΈΧ¨ΦΆΧ”, ΧΦ²Χ€Φ΄Χ™ΧœΦΌΧ•ΦΌ גַּוָּא Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ—ΦΈΧ‘Φ΄Χ™Χͺָא Χ ΦΈΧžΦ΅Χ™ מִΧͺΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ·Χ¨! Χ›ΦΌΦΉΧ—Φ· Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ’Χ•ΦΉΧ™ ΧžΦ΄Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦΈΧ Φ·ΧŸ הוּא דַּאֲבִיר, הַהוּא Χ“ΦΌΦ΄Χ Φ°Χ€Φ·Χ§ ΧœΦ°Χ‘ΦΈΧ¨Φ·ΧΧ™ β€” Χ’ΦΌΦ°Χ–Φ·Χ¨Χ•ΦΌ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦΈΧ Φ·ΧŸ, הַהוּא Χ“ΦΌΦ΄ΧœΦ°Χ’Φ·Χ•ΦΌΦ·ΧΧ™ β€” לָא Χ’ΦΌΦ°Χ–Φ·Χ¨Χ•ΦΌ Χ‘ΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦΈΧ Φ·ΧŸ.

The Gemara raises an objection to this interpretation: If the reference is to a gentile who pours the wine, even the wine inside the barrel is rendered forbidden, because the gentile is also powering the movement of the barrel itself. The Gemara responds to this objection: The halakha that a gentile’s force renders wine forbidden is by rabbinic law. With regard to the wine that is poured out of the barrel, the Sages decreed that it is forbidden; but with regard to the wine that remains inside the barrel, the Sages did not decree that it is forbidden.

אֲמַר ΧœΦ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ חִבְדָּא ΧœΦ°Χ”ΦΈΧ Φ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ Χ‘ΦΈΧ‘ΦΉΧ™ΦΈΧͺָא: Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ™ Χ›ΦΈΧ™Φ°Χ™ΧœΦ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΌ Χ—Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ ΧœΦ°Χ’Χ•ΦΉΧ™Φ΄Χ β€” (Χ§ΦΈΧ˜Φ°Χ€Φ΄Χ™) [Χ§Φ·Χ˜ΦΌΦ΄Χ™Χ€Χ•ΦΌ] Χ§Φ·Χ˜ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ€Φ΅Χ™, אִי Χ ΦΈΧžΦ΅Χ™ (Χ ΦΈΧ€Φ°Χ¦Φ΄Χ™) [Χ Φ·Χ€ΦΌΦ΄Χ™Χ¦Χ•ΦΌ] Χ Φ·Χ€ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ¦Φ΅Χ™. אֲמַר ΧœΦ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ רָבָא ΧœΦ°Χ”ΦΈΧ Φ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ שָׁ׀וֹכָא֡י: Χ›ΦΌΦ΄Χ™ שָׁ׀ְכִיΧͺΧ•ΦΌ Χ—Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ β€” לָא ΧœΦ΄Χ™Χ§Φ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ Χ’ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ™ ΧœΦ°Χ‘Φ·Χ™ΦΌΦ·Χ™Χ’ Χ‘ΦΌΦ·Χ”Φ²Χ“Φ·Χ™Φ°Χ™Χ›Χ•ΦΌ, Χ“ΦΌΦ΄ΧœΦ°ΧžΦΈΧ מִשְׁΧͺΦΌΦ°ΧœΦ΄Χ™ΧͺΧ•ΦΌ וְשָׁד֡יΧͺΧ•ΦΌ ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ’Φ²ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ, וְקָאָΧͺΦ΅Χ™ ΧžΦ΄Χ›ΦΌΦΉΧ—Χ•ΦΉ וַאֲבִיר.

The Gemara relates accounts of how the Sages ruled concerning this matter: Rav αΈ€isda said to certain wine retailers: When you measure wine for gentiles, pour with interruptions, rather than in a smooth steady stream, or toss it out in a single action that does not create a steady stream. Rava said to certain wine pourers: When you pour wine, do not let a gentile approach to help you, lest you let your guard down and rest the vessel in the gentile’s hands, and the wine will emerge due to his force and will be rendered forbidden.

הָהוּא גַּבְרָא דְּאַבּ֡יק Χ—Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ בְּגִישְׁΧͺָּא Χ•ΦΌΧ‘Φ·Χͺ גִּישְׁΧͺָּא, אֲΧͺָא Χ’ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ™ אַנַּח Χ™Φ°Χ“Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ אַגִּישְׁΧͺָּא, אַבְר֡יהּ רָבָא ΧœΦ°Χ›Χ•ΦΌΧœΦΌΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ—Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ.

The Gemara relates: There was an incident involving a certain man who siphoned wine from a barrel with a large tube and a small tube. A gentile came and rested his hand upon the large tube. Rava deemed the entire quantity of wine forbidden, including the wine that was still in the barrel.

אֲמַר ΧœΦ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ ׀ָּ׀ָּא ΧœΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ‘ΦΈΧ, Χ•Φ°ΧΦΈΧžΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™ ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ אַדָּא Χ‘ΦΌΦ·Χ¨ מַΧͺΦ°Χ ΦΈΧ” ΧœΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ‘ΦΈΧ, Χ•Φ°ΧΦΈΧžΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™ ΧœΦ·Χ”ΦΌ רָבִינָא ΧœΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ‘ΦΈΧ: Χ‘ΦΌΦ°ΧžΦ·ΧΧ™? Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§. שָׁמְגַΧͺΦΌΦ° ΧžΦ΄Χ™Χ ΦΌΦ·Χ”ΦΌ Χ Φ΄Χ¦ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ§ Χ—Φ΄Χ™Χ‘ΦΌΧ•ΦΌΧ¨? שָׁאנ֡י Χ”ΦΈΧͺָם, Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ›Χ•ΦΌΧœΦΌΦ΅Χ™ Χ—Φ·ΧžΦ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ אַגִּישְׁΧͺָּא Χ•ΦΌΧ‘Φ·Χͺ גִּישְׁΧͺָּא Χ’ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ΄Χ™Χ¨.

Rav Pappa said to Rava, and some say it was Rav Adda bar Mattana who said this to Rava, and some say it was Ravina who said this to Rava: By what mechanism was the wine rendered forbidden? Was it by the stream of wine that went through the large tube, which was rendered forbidden by the contact of the gentile, and the rest of the barrel was rendered forbidden by the connection with that stream? Should one conclude from this ruling that a stream constitutes a connection? Rava rejects this inference: It is different there, as all of the wine in the barrel is drawn toward the large tube and the small tube, and so it is as though the gentile had touched all of the wine in the barrel.

אָמַר מָר Χ–Χ•ΦΌΧ˜Φ°Χ¨ΦΈΧ Χ‘ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ΅Χ™Χ”ΦΌ Χ“ΦΌΦ°Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ Χ Φ·Χ—Φ°ΧžΦΈΧŸ: Χ§Φ°Χ Φ΄Χ™Χ©ΧΦ°Χ§Φ°Χ Φ΄Χ™ΧŸ שְׁר֡י, Χ•Φ°Χ”ΦΈΧ Φ΅Χ™ ΧžΦ΄Χ™ΧœΦΌΦ΅Χ™ דִּקְד֡ים Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ·Χ§ Χ™Φ΄Χ©Χ‚Φ°Χ¨ΦΈΧΦ΅Χœ, ΧΦ²Χ‘ΦΈΧœ קְד֡ם Χ€ΦΌΦ°Χ‘Φ·Χ§ Χ’ΦΌΧ•ΦΉΧ™ β€” לָא. Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ΦΌΦΈΧ” Χ‘ΦΌΦ·Χ¨ Χ¨Φ·Χ‘ הוּנָא ΧΦ΄Χ™Χ§ΦΌΦ°ΧœΦ·Χ’ ΧœΦ°Χ‘Φ΅Χ™ ר֡ישׁ Χ’ΦΌΦΈΧœΧ•ΦΌΧͺָא, שְׁרָא ΧœΦ°Χ”Χ•ΦΌ לְמִשְׁΧͺּ֡א Χ‘ΦΌΦ΄Χ§Φ°Χ Φ΄Χ™Χ©ΧΦ°Χ§Φ°Χ Φ΄Χ™ΧŸ.

Mar Zutra, son of Rav NaαΈ₯man, says: For a Jew and a gentile to drink simultaneously from a vessel with tubes for several people to drink from [kenishkanin] is permitted. And this statement applies only in a case where the Jew stops drinking first, before the gentile; but if the gentile stops drinking first, it does not apply and the wine is forbidden, as wine from the gentile’s mouth returns to the vessel and renders all of the wine forbidden. Rabba bar Rav Huna happened to come to the house of the Exilarch, and he permitted them to drink from a kenishkanin together with gentiles.

Want to follow content and continue where you left off?

Create an account today to track your progress, mark what you’ve learned, and follow the shiurim that speak to you.

Clear all items from this list?

This will remove ALL the items in this section. You will lose any progress or history connected to them. This is irreversible.

Cancel
Yes, clear all

Are you sure you want to delete this item?

You will lose any progress or history connected to this item.

Cancel
Yes, delete