On the view that the tenth animal is automatically consecrated as the tithe. But what if one calls the ninth one “the tenth”? The ninth would be eaten in a blemished state, and the tenth would be considered the tithe. Note that what the owner calls each animal in the count has impact on the consecration of the tenth. Also, the case of the owner of 14 lambs, all of which are in the pen for counting the tithe. Then 6 leave one side of the pen and 10 leave the other side, which is 10, but they aren’t together, so they don’t combine for the tithe. With other permutations of the same, of course.

Get Beyond the Daf via podcast
All Hadran Beyond the Daf weekly classes are available on our Beyond the Daf podcast.
Pick your podcast platform of choice:




